Commercial multifamily real estate has historically been a proven asset class as it fulfills the human desire for safe, clean, and functioning housing. Multifamily has performed very well in the last decade, and in spite of its extended price appreciation, the outlook for this asset class remains favorable. Even with several fundamental drivers still in-place, investors should be mindful of current dynamics when evaluating multifamily investment opportunities.
1. Decreasing Homeownership - Increasing rental households due to several factors such as increasing underemployment, stagnating wage growth, increasing consumer debt, changing lifestyle preferences in favor of renting, and tightening of mortgage lending standards. The hurdles to homeownership continue to increase for many people in the U.S.
Despite having an unemployment rate of around 4% at the lowest rate since 1976, this is not a complete picture as many Americans are "underemployed." For instance, highly skilled workers who can get only low-skilled/lower-paying jobs would be classified as underemployed. Underemployment is challenging to measure and is not officially tracked by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, but the Economic Policy Institute published a paper in May 2018, which found the rate to be 11.1%.
Many Americans have had real incomes flat-line or decrease since 2000, according to the Bipartisan Policy Center's Report of the Commission on Retirement Security and Personal Savings. An increasing number of Americans are facing barriers to income and wealth growth and also homeownership.
2. Demographic Shifts - Major demographic shifts have been taking place. U.S. population growth continues to increase with approximately half of the total population consisting of two groups: Baby Boomers (born between 1946 and 1964) and Millennials (born between 1981 and 1996). Millennials now comprise the largest share of the U.S. population and labor force. This group is expected to create up to 25 million new households between 2015 and 2025 and have a strong preference in favor of renting. Baby Boomers and Millennials are significant to multifamily demand because the largest group of renters is those age 20 to 34, and the fastest-growing group of renters is those age 55 and older. Also, immigration is expected to account for approximately half of the new population growth in the U.S. Immigrants have historically shown a much higher likelihood to rent than own and to do so for longer periods of time.
Projected Total U.S. Population - 2020 to 2060
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2017 National Population Projections
Projected U.S. Population of Predominant Renter Age Groups - 2020 to 2060
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2017 National Population Projections
3. Constrained Supply - It is estimated that construction of 4,600,0000 multifamily units will be needed by 2030 to keep pace with demand. Meeting the demand is being hampered by factors such as unnecessary government regulations, increasing construction-related costs, rent control, and concentration of new supply.
According to a research study conducted by the National Multifamily Housing Council and the National Association of Home Builders, an average of 32% of multifamily development costs were due to regulations imposed by all levels of government. This is a staggering component of the total cost of multifamily development projects and serves as a sizeable hurdle to development and, particularly, with regard to affordable housing units.
Multifamily housing development is increasingly expensive due to the costs of vacant commercial land and construction (labor, materials, and contractor fees), according to the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University. Between 2012 and 2017, the inflation rate was only 7%, but land and construction-related costs increased by 62% and 25%, respectively.
In 2019, California, Oregon, and New York passed rent control laws with the most stringent taking place in New York. Since 2017, more than a dozen other states have either considered legislation and/or ballot initiatives to limit rent growth. Based on these developments, the continued push for more rent control is likely. Unfortunately, these laws disincentivize continued development of new units and investment in existing units.
Based on a 2018 fact sheet from the National Multifamily Housing Council and National Apartment Association, supply has been further constrained due to the loss of up to 125,000 multifamily units every year due to destruction, demolition, and deterioration. Also, the loss of multifamily units tends to be concentrated in lower-end workforce housing, which has been decreasing in supply.
Construction of new units has concentrated geographically and/or mainly in higher-end Class "A" properties. According to the March 2017 report by Fannie Mae, approximately 25% of multifamily construction occurred in five cities: Boston, Los Angeles, New York, San Francisco, and Washington D.C. Developers will construct based on the project's (investment) yield, and this does not necessarily correspond to what unit type is most needed. The construction of mid to lower-end multifamily units is financially challenging or nonviable in high-cost markets/areas as these same areas would highly favor the development of higher-end units. However, these higher-end units fail to address the growing demand for affordable units.
Take Away for Investors
The constrained supply and growing demand for multifamily may take one or more decades to balance out as it requires almost 350,000 units per year. The increase in rental households due to factors such as underemployment and stagnant wage growth means that a sizable portion of the demand is for workforce housing units. In high-cost markets, the construction of higher-end units is heavily favored, but these units fail to adequately address the increasing demand for affordable units.
Given the multiyear price appreciation in multifamily real estate, it is likely that valuations in some markets are at or near the top of the current real estate cycle. The fundamentals continue to favor multifamily investments, but investors will need to be highly selective when reviewing potential opportunities. Investors looking for lower-risk opportunities may want to focus on vetted secondary and tertiary markets that serve moderate and low-income households.